“Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me. I lift my lamp beside the golden door!” …Emma Lazarus
The tall Lady Liberty has called out her message to the world and welcomed strangers and returning citizens for 127 years; the torch bearer and symbol of American freedom, compassion and promise.
My parents took me topside to see her when we retuned from Europe in the mid-thirties. Their pride in being Americans was unbounded in that moment. It was less than forty years earlier my grandparents had looked at the Lady as they were completing their journey to a new life.
My grandparents left German Pomerania to escape a life of never ending poverty in answer to the call of Lady Liberty. In mid-America they found work as gardeners, had a house, small vegetable garden and chickens, and raised a family of ten. The next generation went to school, fought for America in the Great War, worked in factories and had dairy farms. Their children, the third generation of Americans, went on to college to become engineers and other professionals.
The Lady kept her promise to my grandparents and millions of other immigrants.
But, that was America then. Did the horror of September 11, 2001, bring about the basic change in America and Lady Liberty’s call to homeless and oppressed. Probably not; hopefully, not. It did, however, unlock the fears and paranoia of several million Americans and our politics, welfare and freedom have not been the same since that day. Lady Liberty and her message have become an inconvenient embarrassment to many. Immigrants are seen as much of the problem.
Charles Blow of the New York Times described this new America in an August 9 article.
“…I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
No more.
Today’s America — at least as measured by the actions and inactions of the pariahs who roam its halls of power and the people who put them there — is insular, cruel and uncaring.
In this America, people blame welfare for creating poverty rather than for mitigating the impact of it. “Too much welfare that prevents initiative.”
In this America, the House can — as it did in July — pass a farm bill that left out the food stamp program at a time when a record number of Americans, nearly 48 million, are depending on the benefits.
In this America, a land of immigrants, comprehensive immigration reform can be stalled in The People’s Branch of government, and anti-reform mouthpieces like Ann Coulter and Pat Buchanan can warn that immigration reform will be the end of the country.
With 11 million undocumented immigrants living in the shadows of American society, one would think that comprehensive immigration reform would be a most important issue to resolve, and quickly.
No, War has dominated and influenced the American psyche. On this 12th anniversary of Nine-eleven, Americans have thought, planned and sent our young men and women to fight in wars for all of those twelve years. And it seems to have poisoned our compassion and reason. Like addicts, most Americans are weary of war, but can’t seem to leave it behind.
Now, the President that we elected in 2008, with the hope of many, to bring peace and reason back, has pushed aside a promising new effort for immigration reform to use all his energy for another war.
The Lady can do nothing but weep.